Why Doing Nothing Can Sometimes Be the Best Investment Decision
Imagine you've just watched the evening news. Sharemarkets have fallen sharply, economists are warning of difficult times ahead and commentators are debating whether things are about to get considerably worse.
You look at your investment portfolio and discover that its value has fallen too.
What should you do?
For many investors, the natural response is to do something. Perhaps sell some shares, move money into cash or switch to investments that appear safer.
After all, doing nothing when something is going wrong can feel irresponsible.
But here's a question worth considering: What if doing nothing is actually the most sensible decision you can make?
After three decades working as a financial planner, I've come to appreciate that good investment management isn't simply about knowing what to buy or sell. It's also about recognising when the best course of action is to leave things alone.
And that can be surprisingly difficult.
Why we feel compelled to act
Human beings aren't particularly comfortable with uncertainty.
When something threatens our financial security, our instinct is to regain control. Taking action makes us feel as though we're addressing the problem, even when we don't have enough information to know whether that action will improve the outcome.
Investment markets provide plenty of opportunities for this instinct to take over.
There is always something happening. Interest rates are changing, governments are announcing policies, companies are reporting results and commentators are predicting what might happen next.
Much of this information is interesting. Some of it is genuinely important. But very little of it necessarily requires an immediate change to a long-term investment portfolio.
Nevertheless, the constant stream of information can create the impression that successful investing demands constant attention and activity.
It doesn't.
In fact, unnecessary trading can introduce additional costs, potential tax consequences and the risk of making decisions based on short-term events that have little bearing on an investor's long-term objectives.
The difference between being informed and being reactive
At The Updated Investor, we spend considerable time monitoring investments, reviewing research and considering developments that might affect our clients' portfolios.
But monitoring a portfolio and continually changing it are two very different things.
The purpose of our research isn't to find an excuse to make a transaction. It's to establish whether the reasons we selected an investment remain valid.
Has the investment manager changed their approach? Have the underlying risks increased? Is the investment still fulfilling its intended role? Has something happened that genuinely changes our assessment of its future prospects?

These are questions worth asking.
On the other hand, the fact that an investment has fallen in value, or that another investment has performed better over the past six months, doesn't necessarily mean we should make a change.
Markets move. Investment styles fall in and out of favour. Even good investments can experience extended periods of disappointing returns.
The challenge is distinguishing between a temporary setback and a fundamental problem.
That requires judgement, research and discipline, not simply a willingness to trade.
Sometimes the greatest danger is abandoning the plan
Consider an investor who holds a diversified portfolio designed to support their retirement over the next twenty years.
The portfolio has been constructed with sufficient accessible reserves to meet foreseeable living expenses, while the balance remains invested for longer-term growth and income.
Then markets fall significantly.
If the investor sells their growth investments and moves into cash, they may avoid further losses if markets continue to decline.
But what happens next?
At some point, they must decide when to reinvest.
And therein lies the problem. Successfully moving out of the market requires not just one good decision, but two: knowing when to sell and knowing when to buy back.
Neither decision is easy, particularly when the news remains unsettling.
History has repeatedly shown that markets can recover before the economic outlook starts to look reassuring. Investors waiting for certainty may find that much of the recovery has already occurred before they feel comfortable returning.
Of course, recoveries aren't guaranteed, and some investments never regain their previous value.
But selling simply because markets have fallen can turn a temporary decline into a realised loss while introducing the further risk of missing a subsequent recovery.
That's why the quality of the original financial plan matters so much.
If a portfolio has been constructed around realistic objectives, appropriate diversification and a clear understanding of when money will be needed, the investor may be better equipped to withstand difficult market conditions without being forced into unnecessary decisions.
Doing nothing doesn't mean neglecting your investments
There's a distinction here that I think is often overlooked.
Doing nothing can be the result of careful analysis, or it can be the consequence of failing to pay attention.
They are not the same thing.
A portfolio that hasn't been reviewed for years may contain investments that are no longer appropriate. Asset allocations may have changed significantly, investment managers may have departed and the investor's personal circumstances may be entirely different.
That isn't disciplined investing. It's neglect.
Equally, there will be occasions when action is clearly warranted.
An investment may no longer meet our requirements. The client's cashflow needs may have changed. A portfolio may have become overly concentrated following strong performance in one particular sector.
Or an investment may have developed liquidity, governance or valuation concerns that undermine the original reasons for holding it.
In these circumstances, doing nothing could be precisely the wrong decision.
The important point is that investment decisions should be driven by a sound reason to act, not simply by the feeling that something ought to be done.
Good investment management is a process, not a series of predictions
This brings us to another part of our investment philosophy.
I don't believe successful long-term investing depends on continually anticipating the next economic event or identifying the next winning investment.
As we've discussed throughout this series, the future is inherently uncertain.
Instead, we aim to establish an investment process that can operate sensibly through changing conditions.
That means selecting investments for clearly defined reasons, understanding how they fit together, monitoring whether those reasons remain valid and making adjustments when there is sufficient justification.
It also means accepting that not every investment will perform well all the time.
There will inevitably be periods when a particular fund manager, asset class or investment approach disappoints.
If we abandon an investment every time that happens, we risk spending our time chasing what has already performed well rather than maintaining a coherent long-term strategy.
Sometimes, after reviewing the evidence, the appropriate conclusion is that nothing material has changed.
And sometimes the best decision is to make no change at all.

The value of an adviser isn't measured by the number of transactions
This is something I've thought about increasingly over my career.
Clients engage financial advisers because they want sound judgement, guidance and greater confidence in their financial decisions.
Yet there can be an assumption that the value of investment advice must be demonstrated through activity. If nothing has been bought or sold, what exactly has the adviser been doing?
I think this misunderstands the nature of good advice.
An adviser who thoroughly reviews a client's portfolio and concludes that it remains appropriate may have provided just as much value as one who recommends several changes.
In fact, avoiding an unnecessary transaction can sometimes be more valuable than making one.
The work lies in understanding the client's circumstances, assessing the evidence, challenging assumptions and determining whether action is warranted.
It also involves helping clients maintain perspective when market conditions become unsettling.
At TUI, we believe advice is the product. Its value should be measured by the quality of decisions it supports and the outcomes it helps clients achieve, rather than the number of transactions undertaken.
Patience is easier when you have Financial Certainty
There's another reason why financial planning should come before investment selection.
It's much easier to remain patient during difficult markets when you know your immediate financial needs are taken care of.
Someone who has sufficient accessible funds to meet their foreseeable expenses is generally in a better position to leave their longer-term investments alone.
Someone who is uncertain about how they'll meet next year's living costs may feel compelled to sell investments, regardless of whether market conditions are favourable.
This is why our approach to Financial Certainty begins with understanding cashflow, financial commitments and the resources needed to support a client's lifestyle.
A sound financial plan doesn't eliminate market volatility or guarantee investment returns.
What it can do is reduce the likelihood that short-term market movements will force decisions that compromise long-term objectives.
And that creates something valuable: the freedom to be patient.
Knowing when to act, and when not to
There will always be another economic prediction, another investment opportunity and another reason to worry about financial markets.
Some will deserve our attention. Others will prove to be little more than noise.
The difficulty lies in telling the difference.
I don't believe investors need to respond to every development, nor do I believe that a portfolio should remain unchanged regardless of circumstances.
What matters is having a clear understanding of why investments are held, what would justify changing them and how those decisions relate to the investor's broader financial objectives.
Sometimes that will lead to decisive action.
Sometimes it will lead to a careful decision to stay the course.
And sometimes the greatest contribution a financial adviser can make is helping a client avoid a decision they may later regret.
Doing nothing isn't always the right investment decision. But when it follows careful consideration and a sound financial plan, it can be one of the most valuable decisions we make.
This is Article 7 in The Updated Investor's 12-part Investment Series, exploring practical investment principles to help people make better financial decisions and achieve greater Financial Certainty.
General information only. This article does not take account of your personal objectives, financial situation or needs. Consider whether the information is appropriate for your circumstances before making financial decisions.







Comments