What Makes Us Sell an Investment?
The Updated Investor | Investment Series: Article 9 of 12
One of the more interesting questions in investment management is not what makes us buy an investment, but what makes us sell one.
It's a question worth considering because investors often assume that selling an investment must mean something has gone wrong.
Perhaps its performance has disappointed. Perhaps markets have changed. Or perhaps we've identified another investment that we believe will deliver better returns.
Sometimes those explanations are relevant. But they don't necessarily describe the way we approach investment decisions at The Updated Investor.
In fact, there are occasions when we will retain an investment despite disappointing performance, just as there are occasions when we will sell an investment that has performed exceptionally well.
That might sound contradictory.
But the distinction comes down to something we've discussed throughout this series.
Good investment decisions should be based on sound reasoning, not simply on what has happened to investment prices.
Every investment should have a purpose
When we select an investment for a portfolio, we should be able to explain why it is there.
That might seem obvious, but it's an important discipline.
We don't select investments simply because they have performed well or because someone believes they will be next year's winners.
We select them because they offer particular characteristics that we believe will contribute to the overall portfolio.
For example, one Australian share manager might specialise in identifying undervalued businesses, while another might concentrate on companies with attractive long-term growth prospects.
Their investment approaches are different, and we wouldn't necessarily expect them to perform equally well under all market conditions.
An international investment manager may provide exposure to businesses, industries and economies that aren't well represented in Australia.
A fixed interest investment may provide diversification, some stability or an appropriate source of defensive exposure.
Each investment has a role.
And that role should be understood in the context of the broader portfolio and, ultimately, the client's financial circumstances.
The question we need to keep asking is whether the investment continues to perform the role for which it was selected.

When disappointing performance isn't a reason to sell
Imagine we've selected two investment managers.
One follows a value-oriented investment approach, seeking businesses that appear relatively inexpensive compared with their underlying worth.
The other concentrates on companies expected to achieve stronger earnings growth.
Over several years, investors become increasingly enthusiastic about growth companies, and their share prices rise substantially.
The growth manager delivers excellent returns, while the value manager struggles.
Should we replace the value manager?
Not necessarily.
If we selected that manager to provide a different investment style, then a period of underperformance may simply reflect the prevailing market environment.
Selling the manager because its particular style has fallen out of favour could undermine the very diversification we were trying to achieve.
Indeed, the next period of market leadership might look entirely different.
But this doesn't mean we should automatically accept poor performance.
We still need to examine whether the manager is delivering what we reasonably expected.
Has the investment process changed? Are the investment decisions consistent with the manager's stated philosophy? Has the manager performed reasonably against relevant peers? Are the people responsible for investment decisions still in place?
These are far more useful questions than simply asking whether another investment produced a higher return last year.
When good performance isn't a reason to stay
Now consider the opposite situation.
An investment has delivered very attractive returns, perhaps outperforming its competitors over several years.
But something has changed.
The investment manager might have lost key personnel, changed ownership or altered the process that originally attracted us.
Alternatively, the investment may have become increasingly concentrated in particular companies, industries or investment styles.
Its liquidity characteristics may have changed, or its underlying investments may no longer meet our criteria.
Should we continue holding it because its historical returns have been impressive?
I would argue that we shouldn't.
There is an important distinction between an investment that has been successful and one that remains appropriate.
Past performance tells us what has happened. It doesn't necessarily tell us whether the original reasons for holding the investment remain valid.
And that's really what we're trying to establish.
We should retain an investment because it continues to deserve its place in the portfolio, not simply because it has rewarded us in the past.
This can be particularly difficult for investors to accept.
We naturally become attached to investments that have performed well.
Selling a successful investment can feel like abandoning something that has served us faithfully.
But an investment portfolio shouldn't be managed on the basis of loyalty.
Investment management requires ongoing scrutiny
At The Updated Investor, our investment review process considers considerably more than recent performance.
We want to understand whether an investment continues to satisfy the criteria that justified its selection.
That includes the investment philosophy, the people responsible for implementing it, the structure of the investment, the underlying assets, diversification, liquidity and the costs involved.
We also consider whether the investment continues to make an appropriate contribution to the overall portfolio.
Sometimes an investment remains sound in isolation but is no longer required in the same proportion because other portfolio holdings provide similar exposure.
At other times, a change in the client's circumstances may justify a different investment structure, even though the existing investments remain perfectly acceptable.
This is an important distinction.
An investment can be good without being the right investment for a particular person or portfolio.
The importance of independence
There is another consideration that influences the way we approach these decisions.
As discussed in the previous article, Whose Interests Are Really Behind Your Financial Advice?, The Updated Investor doesn't manufacture its own investment products.
We don't have a commercial obligation to retain a particular investment because it belongs to our organisation.
Nor should an investment's continuing inclusion in a portfolio depend upon the revenue it generates for the advice business.
That separation provides us with the freedom to assess investments according to their merits and the needs of our clients.
It doesn't guarantee that every decision will be correct.
No investment adviser can make that promise.
But it helps ensure that the decision to buy, retain or sell an investment can be made without having to protect the commercial interests of an in-house investment product.
For us, that is an important part of genuinely independent financial advice.
Knowing when to do nothing
In Article 7, Why Doing Nothing Can Sometimes Be the Best Investment Decision, we explored the danger of responding unnecessarily to market movements.
That principle remains central to our approach.
But there is an important difference between doing nothing because we have carefully considered the circumstances and doing nothing because we haven't been paying attention.
The first may represent sound investment discipline.
The second is simply neglect.
A disciplined investment manager must be prepared to tolerate periods of disappointing performance when the reasons for holding an investment remain sound.
Equally, that manager must be prepared to act when circumstances change, even if the investment has continued to perform well.
The challenge is knowing the difference.
A decision isn't necessarily wrong because the outcome disappoints
There's one final point worth making.
We shouldn't judge the quality of every investment decision solely by what happens afterwards.
An investment we sell may subsequently perform very well.
An investment we retain may continue to disappoint for some time.
That doesn't automatically mean our original assessment was wrong.
We can only make decisions using the information available at the time, together with a reasonable assessment of the opportunities and risks involved.
Of course, we should review our decisions and learn from mistakes.
But if we assess every decision solely with the benefit of hindsight, we risk confusing good fortune with good judgement.
The objective isn't to demonstrate that we can consistently identify the best-performing investments.
It's to maintain a portfolio whose individual investments continue to make a worthwhile contribution to the client's financial plan.
And that requires patience, scrutiny and, occasionally, the willingness to make changes.
Good investment management isn't about being constantly active. It's about having sound reasons for the decisions we make, including the decision to do nothing.
In our next article, we'll explore how that same discipline applies to the balance of investments within a portfolio, and why rebalancing has much more to do with maintaining an appropriate investment strategy than predicting what markets will do next.
This is Article 9 in The Updated Investor's 12-part Investment Series, exploring the principles behind sound investment decisions and greater Financial Certainty.
General information only. This article does not take account of your personal objectives, financial situation or needs. Consider whether the information is appropriate for your circumstances before making financial decisions.







Comments