top of page

Whose Interests Are Really Behind Your Financial Advice?

4 days ago
7 min read

Updated: 4 days ago

Article 8 of 12 | The Updated Investor's Investment Series


Imagine walking into a car dealership and asking the salesperson which car would be best for your circumstances.


You explain how much driving you do, the size of your family, what you're prepared to spend and what matters most to you.


The salesperson listens carefully, asks some sensible questions and recommends a vehicle that seems entirely appropriate.


But there's something worth remembering. The salesperson works for a particular manufacturer, or a dealership representing a limited range of brands.


That doesn't mean the recommendation is wrong. The vehicle might be excellent and ideally suited to your needs.


It does mean, however, that you probably wouldn't expect the salesperson to consider every vehicle available in Australia.


Now consider what happens when you seek financial advice.

Are you receiving advice about what's best for you, or what's best for you from the products and services the organisation providing the advice has available?

The difference can be important, particularly when we're making decisions that may affect our financial wellbeing for decades.



When advice and product manufacturing become intertwined

For much of my career, financial advice in Australia has had a close relationship with the institutions that manufacture and distribute financial products.


Banks, insurance companies, investment managers and superannuation funds have all been involved, in various ways, in providing financial advice.


There are understandable commercial reasons for this. Financial institutions already have relationships with customers, considerable financial resources and the infrastructure needed to provide investment and superannuation services.


But combining the provision of advice with the manufacture or distribution of financial products creates a potential conflict of interest.


An organisation might receive revenue from providing advice while also earning fees from managing or administering the investments recommended to its clients.


In effect, there may be more than one opportunity for the organisation to earn revenue from the same client's money.


This doesn't automatically mean the advice is inappropriate. Nor does it mean the adviser is consciously favouring their employer's products.


The concern is more fundamental.


When an organisation benefits commercially from particular recommendations, how do we ensure those interests don't influence the advice being provided?


The problem isn't necessarily the adviser

I've known many capable, conscientious financial advisers who have worked within large financial institutions.


Their professional integrity isn't necessarily the issue.


The difficulty is that an adviser may be operating within a structure that places limitations on the investments, strategies or services they can recommend.


For example, some advice businesses operate with an approved list of investment products. Such lists can provide important research, governance and risk-management benefits.


However, the way a list is constructed also matters.


If the range is narrow or gives preference to products associated with the organisation, otherwise suitable alternatives may not receive the same consideration.


Equally, an adviser might be authorised to provide advice only about particular financial products or aspects of a client's financial circumstances.


These limitations should be understood before assuming that the advice represents a comprehensive assessment of all the available options.


And while Australian financial advisers providing personal advice are subject to legal obligations to act in their clients' best interests, those obligations don't mean every adviser provides the same breadth of service or has access to the same investment choices.


What about advice from your superannuation fund?

This is another area where I think consumers need to understand exactly what they're receiving.

Many superannuation funds provide useful financial information, guidance and access to personal advice. For members with relatively straightforward needs, these services can be valuable.


But not all advice provided through a superannuation fund is comprehensive financial planning.


Some services concentrate on matters such as contribution strategies, insurance within the fund, selecting investment options or transitioning to retirement.


There is nothing inherently wrong with this narrower approach, provided the scope is appropriate and clearly explained.


The difficulty arises when someone assumes that advice about their superannuation is the same as advice about their entire financial life.


Consider a couple approaching retirement. They have money in superannuation, some investments outside super, a mortgage, anticipated expenditure on home improvements and questions about when they might qualify for the Age Pension.


They don't simply need to decide which investment option to select within their super fund.

They need to understand how all these pieces fit together.


Should they repay the mortgage? How much money should remain readily accessible? When should they commence drawing retirement income? How much can they comfortably spend? What happens if one partner needs aged care?


Some superannuation funds can arrange broader financial planning services, sometimes at an additional cost. Others provide more limited assistance.


The important thing is knowing the difference.


Your superannuation is an important part of your financial life, but it isn't your entire financial life.

The questions consumers should be asking

When seeking financial advice, I believe there are some questions everyone should feel comfortable asking.


  • Is the adviser employed by, owned by or otherwise commercially associated with an organisation that manufactures financial products?

  • Does the organisation receive revenue from the investments being recommended, in addition to any advice fees?

  • Can the adviser recommend investments or services from outside their organisation's preferred product range?

  • Will the advice consider the client's broader financial circumstances, or is it limited to particular accounts or products?

  • And perhaps most importantly, if the best recommendation is to do nothing, retain an existing investment or move money elsewhere, is the adviser genuinely free to make that recommendation?


The answers don't automatically determine whether the advice is good or bad. But they help consumers understand the nature of the relationship they're entering.


Financial advice is built on trust, and trust is strengthened by transparency.


Why we've chosen a different approach

At The Updated Investor, we've made a deliberate decision not to manufacture our own investment products or operate investment funds into which we direct our clients' money.


It's a principle that sits at the centre of how we want to conduct our business.


We believe our responsibility is to help clients make better financial decisions, not to create additional opportunities to earn revenue from the investments we recommend.


That doesn't mean we operate without commercial interests or that our approach eliminates every potential conflict. No financial advice business can reasonably make that claim.


We charge for our professional services, and we have a responsibility to ensure that our fees and recommendations are appropriate and transparent.


However, separating the provision of advice from the manufacture of investment products removes an important potential source of conflict.


It means we don't have a financial incentive to recommend a particular investment simply because we manufacture or manage it.


Our investment recommendations must stand on their own merits.


If we believe an investment no longer deserves its place in a client's portfolio, we should be free to recommend replacing it without considering whether doing so would reduce revenue from an associated investment product.


For us, this is about keeping the relationship between the client and the adviser as straightforward as possible.


Financial planning should come before product selection

There's another aspect of this discussion that I believe is even more important.


Much of what determines a person's financial wellbeing has relatively little to do with which investment products they own.


Consider the decisions that can make a meaningful difference to someone's financial future.


Understanding what their lifestyle costs, managing debt, making appropriate insurance arrangements, preparing for retirement, maintaining accessible reserves and deciding how much they can afford to spend are all fundamental financial planning issues.


Investment selection matters, of course. But it should follow from an understanding of those broader circumstances.


This is the thinking behind our approach to Financial Certainty.


We begin by understanding what someone wants their money to achieve, what obligations they need to meet and what might threaten their ability to live comfortably.


Only then do we consider the investment arrangements needed to support those objectives.

Sometimes the most valuable recommendation we can make has nothing to do with buying an investment.


It might involve reorganising someone's cashflow, reducing debt, changing their retirement plans or simply demonstrating that they can afford to enjoy more of their money.


If financial advice is primarily treated as a way of distributing investment products, there's a risk that these broader considerations receive less attention than they deserve.


Advice should be the product

I've long believed that the real value of financial advice lies in the judgement, experience and perspective the adviser brings to a client's circumstances.


It isn't simply the ability to select investments.


A good financial adviser should help people understand their options, identify risks they may not have recognised and make decisions that support the life they want to live.


Sometimes that involves recommending investments. Sometimes it involves recommending against them.


And sometimes, as we discussed in the previous article, it involves explaining why doing nothing is the most sensible course of action.


This is why, at TUI, we believe advice is the product.


The investments are tools we use to help achieve the client's objectives. They aren't the reason the advice relationship exists.


That distinction influences how we approach everything from investment research and portfolio construction to budgeting, retirement planning and ongoing client reviews.


Ultimately, whose interests come first?

None of this suggests that financial institutions or superannuation funds cannot provide good financial advice.


Many do, and there are circumstances where their services may be entirely appropriate.

Nor does the absence of in-house products automatically guarantee good advice. Competence, experience, transparency, professional judgement and effective conflict management all matter.


But I believe consumers should understand the commercial arrangements and limitations that sit behind the advice they receive.


They should know what they're paying for, what their adviser can recommend and whether there are incentives that might influence the advice process.


Most importantly, they should understand whether the advice is designed around their broader financial circumstances or primarily around the products and services available through the provider.


Because the purpose of financial advice shouldn't be to find a home for someone's money.


It should be to help them use their money to live the life they want.


And that, ultimately, is what Financial Certainty is all about.



This is Article 8 in The Updated Investor's 12-part Investment Series, exploring practical investment principles to help people make better financial decisions and achieve greater Financial Certainty.

General information only. This article does not take account of your personal objectives, financial situation or needs. Consider whether the information is appropriate for your circumstances before making financial decisions.


 
 
 

Comments


Contact Us:

02 9712 7313

  • googlePlaces
  • facebook
  • linkedin

General Advice Disclaimer
Any advice contained in this website is of a general nature only and does not constitute personal financial product advice. In providing ths information, no account was taken of the objectives, financial situation or needs of any particular person. Therefore, before making any decision, readers should consider the appropriateness of the information with regard to their particular objectives, financial situation and needs.

©2021 by The Updated Investor Pty Ltd

bottom of page