top of page

The Hidden Risk of Investments That Never Seem to Fall in Value

Oct 30
6 min read

Article 6 of 12 | The Updated Investor's Investment Series


Imagine you own two investments, each worth $100,000.


The first is a diversified portfolio of shares listed on the stock exchange. Every business day, its value changes. Sometimes it rises, sometimes it falls, and occasionally the movements can be quite dramatic.


The second is an investment in an unlisted property or private credit fund. Its reported value barely changes from month to month, and it consistently pays an attractive income.


Which investment would you consider safer?


It's a question worth thinking about, because the answer isn't necessarily as obvious as it might first appear.


We tend to associate stability with safety. If an investment rarely falls in value, we naturally assume it must carry less risk than one whose price fluctuates every day.


But there's an important distinction between an investment whose value is genuinely stable and one whose value simply isn't measured very often.


And confusing the two can prove expensive.


What you see isn't always what you own

One of the characteristics of listed investments is that their prices are determined continuously through transactions between buyers and sellers.


If investors become nervous about the economy, interest rates or the outlook for a particular company, those concerns can quickly be reflected in its share price.


This makes listed investments appear volatile. Every change in market sentiment is visible, whether we like it or not.


Unlisted investments can work quite differently.


Consider a property fund that owns several commercial buildings. Those properties might be independently valued periodically, with their reported values updated between valuations using assumptions or internal processes.


In between, the properties themselves continue to be exposed to changing interest rates, rental markets, economic conditions and investor demand.


The economic risks haven't disappeared simply because there isn't a new market price available every day.


The same principle can apply to private credit and mortgage funds. The underlying loans may be carried at values determined using contractual cashflows, credit assessments and valuation policies rather than prices established through regular market transactions.


Those methods can be perfectly legitimate, but they mean the reported value may behave quite differently from the price at which the investment could actually be sold.


The absence of price movements isn't necessarily evidence of the absence of risk.


The problem with an attractive return and a stable price

One of the attractions of certain unlisted investments is their ability to deliver relatively consistent distributions without the daily fluctuations associated with listed markets.


For an investor seeking income, that can be very appealing.


But whenever I'm presented with an investment offering an attractive return and apparently little volatility, I want to understand where that return comes from and what risks the investor is accepting in exchange.


In the case of private credit, for example, borrowers may pay higher interest rates because they cannot access finance on the same terms as more established or creditworthy borrowers.


That doesn't automatically make the loans inappropriate. However, the additional return may be compensation for additional credit risk, limited liquidity or other obligations that aren't immediately apparent from the fund's reported performance.


Similarly, an unlisted property investment may provide reliable rental income while still being exposed to falling property values, refinancing pressures or difficulties finding buyers when the assets need to be sold.


It's important to distinguish between the income an investment distributes and the total return it ultimately delivers.


A regular distribution doesn't, by itself, establish that an investment is safe or that its underlying capital value is secure.


What happens when everyone wants their money back?

This brings us to another issue that receives far less attention than investment returns: liquidity.

When you invest in a listed security, there is generally an established market in which you can attempt to sell it. That doesn't guarantee you will receive the price you want, particularly during periods of market stress, but there is usually a mechanism for finding a buyer.


With some unlisted investments, withdrawing your money may depend on the fund having sufficient available cash, receiving new investments or selling underlying assets.


And those underlying assets may not be easy to sell.


Imagine a fund that owns commercial properties or provides long-term loans but offers investors the opportunity to request withdrawals at relatively short intervals.


Under normal circumstances, those arrangements might operate smoothly. But what happens if a large number of investors request their money at the same time?


The fund may have little choice but to restrict, delay or suspend withdrawals while it raises sufficient cash.


That doesn't necessarily mean the investment has failed or that its assets are worthless. It does, however, mean that an investor who expected to have access to their money might suddenly discover that they don't.


For someone relying on those funds to meet living expenses, purchase a home or fund retirement, that can be a serious problem.


An investment you cannot access when you need it may be considerably riskier than its reported volatility suggests.

Why liquidity matters to us

At The Updated Investor, liquidity is one of the guiding principles of our investment philosophy.

We generally prefer investments with transparent valuations, readily accessible markets and the ability to realise funds within a relatively short period.


As a broad principle, we look for investments that can ordinarily be converted to cash within approximately seven to fourteen days, although actual settlement and withdrawal arrangements vary.

This isn't because we expect our clients to be constantly buying and selling investments. Quite the opposite. We generally favour a disciplined, long-term approach.


But long-term investing and the ability to access money when necessary are not mutually exclusive.

We want our clients to have choices.


If circumstances change, an unexpected expense arises or we decide an investment no longer deserves its place in a portfolio, we don't want to find ourselves unnecessarily constrained by redemption restrictions or the absence of a practical market.


That said, liquidity doesn't eliminate investment risk. A readily saleable investment can still fall sharply in value, and selling it during a market downturn can crystallise a loss.


That's why we also pay so much attention to cashflow planning, appropriate cash reserves and the timing of anticipated expenditure.


Liquidity provides flexibility. Good financial planning helps us avoid having to use that flexibility at the wrong time.


Does that mean unlisted investments should be avoided?

Not necessarily.


There are legitimate roles for private credit, unlisted property and other less liquid investments in some portfolios. They can offer access to assets, income sources and investment opportunities that aren't always available through listed markets.


But they also introduce considerations that deserve careful examination.


How are the underlying assets valued? Are valuations independently verified? How much of the portfolio is concentrated in particular borrowers or properties? What happens if borrowers default? Is leverage involved? How are withdrawals funded, and under what circumstances can they be suspended?


Perhaps most importantly, is the additional return sufficient compensation for the additional risks and restrictions?


These are questions I believe investors should understand before committing their money.

Our preference at TUI is generally to avoid investments where uncertain valuations, limited transparency or redemption restrictions make it difficult to assess or manage the risks involved.


That approach may mean passing up some attractive opportunities. We accept that because we believe the ability to understand and control risk is more important than pursuing every possible source of additional return.


Financial Certainty is about more than a stable account balance

Over the course of this investment series, we've been exploring why successful investing involves considerably more than selecting investments with impressive performance figures.


The same applies to investments displaying remarkably smooth returns.


A stable account balance can be reassuring, but it doesn't necessarily tell us whether the underlying assets are safe, appropriately valued or accessible when we need them.


For us, Financial Certainty means knowing that our financial arrangements are structured to support our lives, meet our commitments and withstand unexpected events.


That requires us to look beyond the reported returns and ask some important questions about the investments themselves.


What do we actually own? What could go wrong? How would we know if something had gone wrong? And what options would we have if we needed to act?


There will always be uncertainty in investing. Our job isn't to pretend otherwise, but to manage it as sensibly as possible.


Sometimes the investment whose price moves every day is easier to understand and manage than the one whose price hardly moves at all.

And that is something worth remembering the next time an investment promises attractive returns with remarkably little volatility.



This is Article 6 in The Updated Investor's 12-part Investment Series, exploring practical investment principles to help people make better financial decisions and achieve greater Financial Certainty.

General information only. This article does not take account of your personal objectives, financial situation or needs. Consider whether the information is appropriate for your circumstances before making financial decisions.


 
 
 

Comments


Contact Us:

02 9712 7313

  • googlePlaces
  • facebook
  • linkedin

General Advice Disclaimer
Any advice contained in this website is of a general nature only and does not constitute personal financial product advice. In providing ths information, no account was taken of the objectives, financial situation or needs of any particular person. Therefore, before making any decision, readers should consider the appropriateness of the information with regard to their particular objectives, financial situation and needs.

©2021 by The Updated Investor Pty Ltd

bottom of page