Diversification: Why We Don't Try to Pick Tomorrow's Winners
Article 5 of 12 | The Updated Investor's Investment Series
Every year, the investment industry produces lists of the best-performing investments.
The best shares. The best funds. The best sectors. The best countries in which to invest. Every year, investors are tempted to look at those lists and wonder whether they should be putting more of their money into whatever has recently performed the best.
It's understandable. Nobody likes the feeling that someone else is making more money than they are.
But there's a problem with this approach. By the time we know which investments have performed best, the returns we're admiring have already happened.
What matters to an investor isn't what performed best yesterday. It's what will deliver the returns they need tomorrow.
And that's something nobody can predict with certainty.
The problem with picking winners
Imagine that, five years ago, you had been asked to select the five investments that would perform best over the following five years.
How confident would you have been?
You might have identified some excellent businesses, promising technologies or countries with strong economic prospects. But would you have correctly anticipated changes in interest rates, inflation, geopolitical events, government policy or investor sentiment?
Even if you had correctly identified the businesses that would grow most successfully, there's another complication. A great business isn't necessarily a great investment if you pay too much for it.
The price at which you invest matters, just as much as the quality of the investment itself.
This helps explain why yesterday's winners don't necessarily become tomorrow's winners. Expectations change, valuations change and markets often anticipate developments long before they appear in the headlines.
Of course, some investors and fund managers will correctly identify future winners. The difficulty is knowing in advance which ones will do so consistently.
That isn't an argument against investment research. It's an argument for recognising the limits of what research can reliably tell us.
Diversification is an admission that we don't know everything
One of the principles underpinning our investment approach at The Updated Investor is diversification.
Not because we lack confidence in the investments we select, but because we recognise that even the most thoroughly researched investment can produce an unexpected outcome.
We can analyse businesses, examine fund managers, assess economic conditions and consider valuations. We can make informed judgements about where opportunities and risks might lie.
What we cannot do is eliminate uncertainty.
Diversification is a practical response to that reality.
Rather than making our clients' financial futures depend upon a handful of predictions proving correct, we spread investments across different assets, markets, businesses and investment approaches.
The objective is not to own everything. Nor is it to ensure that every investment performs well at the same time.
In fact, if every investment in a portfolio always performs in much the same way, we might reasonably question how much genuine diversification we've achieved.

Why some investments will always disappoint
Here's something that can be difficult for investors to accept.
In a properly diversified portfolio, there will almost always be an investment that has disappointed over the previous year.
Perhaps Australian shares have performed strongly while international shares have lagged. Perhaps one investment manager has delivered excellent returns while another has struggled.
At that moment, it can be tempting to ask why we continue holding the disappointing investment.
But consider what happens if we continually sell whatever has recently performed poorly and buy whatever has performed well.
We risk developing a process in which we repeatedly sell after disappointing returns and buy after strong ones.
That's hardly a reliable formula for long-term investment success.
Of course, there are legitimate reasons to replace an investment. Its management may have changed, its investment strategy may have drifted, its costs may no longer be justified or our original reasons for selecting it may no longer hold.
But recent underperformance, by itself, isn't necessarily evidence that an investment should be abandoned.
Sometimes the very reason an investment is useful in a diversified portfolio is that it behaves differently from the others.
Owning more investments doesn't necessarily mean being more diversified
Suppose an investor owns shares in ten different Australian banks and financial institutions.
They might reasonably say they own ten different investments. But how diversified are they?
Many of those businesses are influenced by similar economic conditions, including interest rates, credit growth, property markets and the health of the Australian economy.
A downturn affecting the financial sector could hurt most of those investments at the same time.
Now consider a portfolio spread across Australian and international shares, fixed interest, cash and different investment styles.
Although each investment carries its own risks, the portfolio is less dependent on any single business, sector or economic outcome.
That doesn't mean every part of the portfolio will behave independently. During severe market disruptions, investments that normally behave differently can fall together.
Nevertheless, thoughtful diversification can reduce the consequences of getting any one investment decision wrong.
The important question is not simply how many investments we own, but how dependent they are on the same things going right.
Diversification requires discipline
There is another important aspect of diversification that receives less attention.
It requires investors to accept that they will rarely achieve the highest possible return.
If technology shares are the best-performing investments in a particular year, a portfolio holding other assets alongside technology shares will probably underperform a portfolio invested entirely in that sector.
But that comparison overlooks the reason the diversified portfolio was constructed in the first place.
We weren't attempting to maximise returns under one particular set of market conditions. We were attempting to build an investment portfolio capable of supporting our financial objectives across a range of possible outcomes.
There's an important distinction between maximising returns and achieving the returns necessary to meet your goals with an acceptable level of risk.
The latter is much closer to what we believe successful investing should be about.
This also explains why diversification shouldn't be confused with constantly adding more investments. Every holding should have a purpose, and its contribution to the overall portfolio should be understood.
How this influences our investment decisions
At The Updated Investor, we use research to identify investments and managers that we believe have a worthwhile role to play in our model portfolios.
We consider their investment approach, the assets they hold, their management, their costs, their liquidity and how they complement the other investments already in the portfolio.
We also pay attention to concentration risk. A portfolio that appears diversified on the surface can still have excessive exposure to a particular company, industry or investment theme when we look through its underlying holdings.
Our approach isn't to assemble a collection of whichever funds happen to have the most impressive recent performance figures.
It's to build portfolios in which the investments work together, recognising that different investments are likely to perform better at different times.
We review those decisions as circumstances change and make adjustments when we believe there's a sound investment reason to do so.
Importantly, diversification is only one part of the process. As we discussed in the previous article, we also need to understand our clients' cashflow requirements, liquidity needs and capacity to withstand investment losses.
A diversified portfolio is not a substitute for good financial planning. It is one of the tools we use to put that planning into practice.
There's another important aspect of our investment philosophy worth mentioning. At The Updated Investor, we don't manufacture investment products, operate our own investment funds or have an obligation to direct clients' money towards products associated with our business. We believe investment selection should be driven by what is appropriate for the client, not by what generates additional revenue for the adviser or their organisation.
This gives us the freedom to consider investment opportunities across the market and to replace an investment when we believe a better alternative is available. It also means that our investment recommendations stand or fall on their merits. We believe this separation between providing financial advice and manufacturing investment products is an important part of managing potential conflicts of interest.
Financial Certainty doesn't depend on picking the winner
I often come back to a simple question when thinking about investment management.
What are we actually trying to achieve?
For most of our clients, the answer isn't to outperform a particular market index or to own the investment that everyone will be talking about next year.
It's to have enough money to live comfortably, meet their commitments, enjoy the opportunities life offers and feel confident about their financial future.
That's what we mean by Financial Certainty.
Diversification supports that objective by reducing our reliance on predictions that might turn out to be wrong.
There will always be opportunities we miss. There will always be investments we own that underperform others. And there will inevitably be occasions when a concentrated investment strategy delivers substantially better returns than our diversified approach.
We accept that.
Because the objective isn't to win every year. It's to make enough good decisions, and avoid enough damaging ones, to give our clients the best reasonable opportunity to achieve what matters to them.
We don't need to know which investment will win next. We need an investment strategy that doesn't depend upon us being right every time.
And that, to my mind, is the real value of diversification.
This is Article 5 in The Updated Investor's 12-part Investment Series, exploring practical investment principles to help people make better financial decisions and achieve greater Financial Certainty.
General information only. This article does not take account of your personal objectives, financial situation or needs. Consider whether the information is appropriate for your circumstances before making financial decisions.







Comments